One epic. Two perspectives. A conversation across ages.
The credits had rolled. The theatre lights were back, and the audience was filing out, carrying three and half hours of gods, kings, demons, celestial weapons, and enough visual spectacle to keep the conversations going well beyond the multiplex.
Two people remained in their seats.
Rasila was admiring the enormous IMAX screen, now blank. Daviku was inspecting his empty popcorn bucket, searching for the enthusiasm he had misplaced somewhere during the film.
“Well?” Rasila asked.
“Well, what?”
“The film, Daviku. What did you make of it?”
“Which one? The spectacle that unfolded whenever Ravana occupied the screen, or the other film?”
Rasila laughed. “You haven’t changed a bit. Must you begin with a complaint?”
“Someone must restore balance. You’ve already crowned it a masterpiece.”
“Not a masterpiece. A magnificent achievement in visual storytelling. Those monumental sets, expansive landscapes, palaces, battlefields! The sheer production scale. Indian cinema has rarely attempted this degree of grandeur for the Ramayana. It deserves the biggest screen one can find.”
“I’ll grant you the grandeur. The money is on the screen. But a magnificent palace doesn’t guarantee a compelling story inside.”
“Nor does one poorly furnished room make an entire kingdom uninhabitable. Shall we discuss what worked before you demolish the palace?”
Daviku gestured for her to continue.
“And the Pushpak Vimana! Full marks for the imagination behind Ravana’s aircraft. The design, the rotating blades, even that grinding mechanical sound accompanying their movement. Such attention to detail!”
“Now that was worth the ticket,” Daviku conceded.
“And the confrontation with Jatayu! The aerial choreography, the visual effects, the clarity of movement. Every maneuver carried danger, every desperate effort from Jatayu carried purpose. The spectacle never lost the sacrifice at its heart.”
“Agreed. One of those rare sequences where technical brilliance and emotion shared the screen without competing for attention.”
Rasila turned towards him. “Two compliments. Shall I summon someone to witness this historic occasion?”
“Don’t test your luck.”
“And we haven’t even discussed the background score,” Rasila continued. “Those action sequences were spellbinding. The sheer force of the orchestration, the tension, the crescendo accompanying every confrontation. Hans Zimmer’s signature was unmistakable. The music gave the spectacle another dimension.”
“I’ll give Zimmer his due,” Daviku replied. “The action sequences had a magnificent score. But what happened to the music when the swords were sheathed?”
“What do you mean?”
“The songs made a sincere attempt at melody, but where was the musical soul of the Ramayana? The cultural texture, the devotional depth, the sounds that could transport us into that period? For a story rooted in Indian mythology and tradition, the music needed more than pleasant melodies. It needed an identity.”
“Surely, you can’t expect every composition to follow the conventions of traditional devotional music. This is a cinematic adaptation, not a religious recital.”
“Nor am I asking for one. But there must be a meeting point between cinematic ambition and cultural authenticity. The background score accompanying the battles was extraordinary. Elsewhere, the songs and score struggled to carry the same conviction. At times, the two belonged to different films.”
Rasila smiled. “So the battles had your approval, but the melodies failed your inspection?”
“Something of that sort. The music could move mountains when the armies marched. I only wish it had moved a few hearts when they stopped.”
They collected their belongings and headed towards the lobby.
“And Yash?” Rasila continued. “What a commanding Ravana! His conquest of Lanka was magnificent. The brutality, the ambition, the authority. That sequence established his motivations and formidable power without requiring an elaborate explanation.”
“Now you’re speaking sense,” Daviku replied. “Yash doesn’t merely enter a scene. He takes possession of it. His conquest of Lanka establishes a man driven by ambition, not merely a villain waiting for his turn in the story.”
“And the ten minds?”
“That was inspired. Rather than reducing Ravana’s ten heads to a visual curiosity, the filmmakers explored the conflicting voices within him. Ten manifestations, one personality pulled in different directions. An inventive interpretation, and Yash gave each manifestation its own character.”
“Three compliments,” Rasila declared. “Perhaps a fourth before we reach the exit?”
“Don’t mistake appreciation for surrender. Speaking of characterization, what happened to Rama?”
“What about him?”
“Where was the man behind the divinity? His early life, his upbringing, the relationships that shaped him. We passed through those chapters with such haste that Sita’s Swayamvara arrived before Rama had acquired sufficient depth on screen.”
“There’s an enormous story to accommodate in two films.”
“Then the screenplay must choose where to spend its time. Breaking Shiva’s bow is a defining moment, but the journey towards it matters. Rama’s virtues cannot depend entirely on the audience arriving with prior knowledge of them.”
“Fair. But Ranbir brought dignity and composure to Rama. Not every virtue needs a dramatic announcement. Restraint has its own strength.”
“Restraint, yes. But there’s a fine line between composure and passivity. Ravana has ambition, fury, conflict, and personality. Rama has righteousness, yet the screenplay rarely allows that righteousness a human dimension. Yash gets the broader dramatic canvas. Ranbir gets the narrower one.”
“And you blame the actor?”
“Not entirely. I’m questioning the characterization.”
“Then direct your criticism at the writing. A character’s quiet strength isn’t a weakness. The failure lies in not giving the audience enough opportunities to experience that strength.”
Daviku paused. “I’ll give you that distinction.”
They reached the café beside the multiplex. Rasila ordered tea. Daviku requested coffee, strong enough to sustain another round of disagreement.
“And Kaikeyi and Dasharatha?” he asked.
Rasila sighed. “I was hoping you’d forgotten.”
“One of the great emotional confrontations of the epic! A father’s anguish, a queen’s internal conflict, the terrible consequences of a promise. And the film rushes through it. Kaikeyi’s demands carry enormous moral weight, yet the confrontation hardly pauses to explore what those demands cost Dasharatha and his family.”
“I won’t defend the haste. That episode deserved more room. But you cannot ask for momentum in one scene and complain when the filmmakers maintain it in another.”
“Momentum must serve the story, Rasila. Not trample its most important moments.”
“Agreed. And a little patience with characters wouldn’t have hurt. Though patience has never been one of your kingdom’s celebrated virtues.”
Daviku gave her a prolonged stare.
“Must everything become a question of kingdoms?”
“Only when you make it one.”
He returned to his coffee.
“Besides, the pacing is an uneven affair. Ravana enters, and the film acquires tremendous energy. Rama returns, and the tempo drops. Then come those impressive battles with the asuras, and the screen springs back to life. The intensity travels between extremes without finding a steady rhythm.”
“Perhaps the contrast was deliberate. Ravana thrives on power and conquest. Rama stands for restraint and duty. Their worlds needn’t move at the same pace.”
“Different temperaments, certainly. But different temperaments shouldn’t produce two different standards of storytelling. Ravana’s scenes have momentum and dramatic purpose. Rama’s world needs more than reverence to sustain our attention.”
“Then that’s where the second part has an opportunity. A grand story needs more than grand entrances.”
They sat for a moment, watching families emerge from the auditorium.
“Still,” Rasila said, “those visual effects were extraordinary.”
“In places. In others, I began questioning whether the characters and their surroundings had ever occupied the same location.”
“Oh, here we go.”
“Some CGI creatures looked artificial. Certain forest environments had the texture of computer-generated scenery, and the green-screen compositions were far from convincing. But the biggest offender was the lighting.”
“The lighting?”
“Consider those outdoor battle scenes. Magnificent backdrops, impressive action, and principal characters illuminated with such intensity that they could have been standing inside a studio. The light on the characters bore little relationship to their surroundings.”
“You’re overlooking how much they achieved.”
“Not at all. I’m questioning the inconsistency. Look at Ravana’s interiors in Lanka. Subdued lighting, darker shades, natural transitions. The atmosphere complemented the architecture and his personality. Then we return to Rama’s kingdom, where everyone is illuminated with the enthusiasm of a thousand strobe lights.”
“Perhaps Ayodhya had an ambitious electricity department.”
“A remarkable accomplishment for an ancient kingdom.”
“Especially one without a power grid,” Rasila added.
They laughed.
Rasila leaned back.
“For all your complaints, Daviku, the undertaking deserves recognition. Generations have experienced this epic through literature, theatre, television, and cinema. This production ventures into territory Indian filmmaking has rarely explored. The craftsmanship, the imagination, the ambition. You can’t dismiss an achievement of this magnitude because certain portions fall short.”
“And I haven’t. But visual ambition cannot exempt a film from criticism. The story deserves the same care given to the spectacle.”
“On that, we agree. You’re demanding greater depth. I’m appreciating what the filmmakers achieved while recognizing what remains unfinished.”
“Then perhaps we aren’t so far apart.”
“An alarming development. Centuries of disagreement, and a film threatens to end it.”
“Don’t worry. There’s another part coming.”
Her phone rang.
Suhaan flashed across the screen.
“Suhaan! We just finished the film,” Rasila answered.
A cheerful voice came through.
“So? Have they done justice to the story?”
“Depends whom you ask,” Daviku called out.
“Ah! He’s with you. I should have guessed. Listen, I’ll join you for Part 2 during Diwali 2028. And this time, I intend to contribute my share of wisdom.”
“Wisdom?” Daviku replied. “That’s a generous promise.”
“Coming from you, I’ll consider that a compliment. Besides, I have an entire army of opinions.”
“Then bring them,” Rasila said. “We’ll need someone to settle our differences.”
Suhaan laughed. “Settle them? After all this time? I’ll have better luck moving a mountain.”
“Let’s begin with getting you to the theatre on time,” Daviku said.
“I’ll be there. Diwali 2028. You have my word.”
The call ended.
Rasila collected her bag.
“Two years. Plenty of time for the filmmakers to strengthen what they’ve begun.”
“And for them to address what they overlooked,” Daviku added.
“And perhaps for you to become more generous.”
“Now you’re demanding the impossible.”
They stepped outside, their disagreement intact and their anticipation for the next chapter undiminished.
The city carried on around them, indifferent to their conversation. Cars moved through the streets, cinema posters glowed above the crowds, and two old acquaintances walked away from a story the world had spent centuries retelling.
For everyone else, it was an evening at the movies. For Rasila and Daviku, the conversation carried a significance neither had cared to explain.
Epilogue:
Rasila and Daviku were no ordinary filmgoers.
Long before multiplexes and computer-generated kingdoms, they had lived in Treta Yuga, the age of the Ramayana. Now reborn in Kali Yuga, they had returned to watch their former world recreated on screen.
Rasila, once an ordinary citizen of Ayodhya, carried the virtues and optimism of her homeland. Her name drew its first two letters from Rama, Sita, and Lakshmana.
Daviku, once an ordinary citizen of Lanka, retained the fierce temperament and critical disposition of the asura kingdom. His name came from Dashanana, Vibhishana, and Kumbhakarna.
And Suhaan, once a citizen among the vanara clan, carried the spirit and wisdom of Sugriva, Hanuman, and Angada.
Three citizens from three kingdoms. Two yugas separating their lives. One epic bringing them together. They had returned to watch a film about the world they once inhabited. Their memories had endured the passage of ages. Their disagreements, evidently, had too.
Beyond the Conversation: An Epic Through Two Lenses
Set aside the reverence, the familiarity, and the weight of centuries for a moment. Walk into the theatre with no allegiance to the epic, no inherited interpretation of its characters, and no expectation beyond a grand cinematic experience.
Through that agnostic lens, the film is an extraordinary spectacle. Its production scale, visual imagination, and technical ambition explore territory that Indian cinema has rarely occupied. There is genuine accomplishment in bringing such an expansive world to the screen, and considerable pleasure in experiencing it at that scale.
With that creative intent and a global fantasy audience in mind, perhaps the film could have taken another route altogether. Package it as a work of pure fiction and fantasy. Give it a title with a different promise. Something along the lines of The Lord and the King: A War Beyond Kingdoms. Liberated from the expectations attached to a sacred epic, its creators might have enjoyed greater freedom to reinvent characters, reimagine conflicts, and pursue their cinematic ambitions without the burden of fidelity.
Of course, such creative freedom would have come with a commercial price. An unfamiliar fantasy would have needed to earn its audience from the ground up. The name Ramayana, on the other hand, arrives with centuries of recognition, devotion, and an audience whose interest needs little introduction. Remove that identity, and those coveted footfalls at the box office would no longer come with quite the same assurance.
But this is not an original fantasy. It is Ramayana.
And that single distinction changes the conversation.
For more than a billion people, the Ramayana occupies a place far beyond literature or cinema. It lives in family traditions, childhood memories, oral histories, cultural practices, and personal convictions. Its characters have inhabited generations of imagination, acquiring meanings that extend beyond any single telling.
For millions, that connection extends into the realm of faith and spiritual reverence. The Ramayana is not merely a story they grew up hearing; it is a sacred presence woven into their beliefs and everyday lives. Such is the depth of that devotion that some carry a sense of sanctity into the cinema itself, extending their respect beyond the characters on screen to the atmosphere and surroundings in which the film is experienced. For them, this is more than an evening of entertainment. It is an encounter with something they hold sacred.
The epic itself has travelled through centuries, across languages and regions, giving rise to numerous literary variations. Each retelling carries its own emphases and interpretations. And within those variations lives another Ramayana, one held in the heart and mind of each individual who has grown up with the story.
For an audience carrying generations of cultural memory, personal conviction, and, in many cases, profound spiritual reverence, leaving that inheritance outside the theatre doors is hardly a reasonable expectation. The film arrives bearing the name Ramayana, drawing upon Valmiki’s epic and inviting expectations that no amount of computer-generated grandeur can erase.
Which brings us to the question at the heart of this review.
Did the film strike a chord with your interpretation of the Ramayana?
For me, the film impressed more consistently as a cinematic production than as a work of dramatic storytelling.
Its greatest achievement lies in recreating the epic’s physical world. The kingdoms acquire scale, the landscapes stretch beyond familiar boundaries, and the battles unfold with extraordinary imagination. The craftsmanship frequently deserves applause.
Yet the epic’s enduring power has never rested upon the magnitude of its kingdoms or the force of its celestial weapons alone. It resides in Dasharatha’s anguish, Kaikeyi’s choices, Rama’s sacrifices, Sita’s resolve, and the moral conflicts that lend each character a profound human dimension.
Did the film capture the grandeur of the Ramayana without losing the humanity that makes it timeless?
The first installment of the film leaves that question unsettled. The filmmakers have recreated the physical world with considerable success. But in their pursuit of spectacle, they may have surrendered some of the emotional world that gives the Ramayana its enduring place in our collective consciousness.
Perhaps the concluding chapter will restore that balance. Perhaps it will strengthen what the first film has established. That judgment belongs to another Diwali.
For now, whether the film succeeds at one, both, or neither remains a matter of individual interpretation. The audience will deliver its verdict, and no two verdicts need be identical. Meanwhile, the crowds continue to arrive, the screens remain occupied, and the cash registers have little reason to complain.
The filmmakers have certainly given the world something to watch. Whether they have given every viewer the Ramayana they carry within themselves is another question.
And perhaps that is the one worth carrying home.
